Page 1 of 1

Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Thu Feb 21, 2019 4:23 am
by DFIH
When I make a new file on Open Office 4.1.6 on Windows 10 I cannot save the file using any method. I can save edits to existing Open Office files, but I cannot use the 'save as' option for existing files. No error message occurs when I try to save, nothing changes onscreen at all. I can make new files only by duplicating old files, deleting the text, rewriting it and then renaming it. This began after installing updates. Looking at other threads on this topic, I successfully renamed the user profile but it did not help. I rebooted the PC in safe mode and that did not help either.

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Thu Feb 21, 2019 4:59 am
by RusselB
Welcome to the forums.
First off, thank you for doing research, trying options and including the results of those attempts. It saves us from suggesting things you've already tried.
That said, my next suggestion is that you try to Repair the installation. As you are using Windows 10 (which I hate with a passion), I can't tell you exactly where to go to do this (sorry).
If the repair doesn't work, or if you can't find how to do the repair, then my next suggestion is to uninstall OpenOffice, download a new copy from http://www.openoffice.org/download then verify the download.
After the download has been verified (instructions are on the download page linked above), reinstall OpenOffice.

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Thu Feb 21, 2019 8:50 am
by robleyd
Can you save new files to the desktop?
 Edit: Or does the Save as option do nothing in all cases? Is this the case for all types of AOO files? 

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Thu Feb 21, 2019 12:30 pm
by jrkrideau
RusselB wrote:Welcome to the forums.
First off, thank you for doing research, trying options and including the results of those attempts. It saves us from suggesting things you've already tried.
That said, my next suggestion is that you try to Repair the installation. As you are using Windows 10 (which I hate with a passion), I can't tell you exactly where to go to do this (sorry).
If the repair doesn't work, or if you can't find how to do the repair, then my next suggestion is to uninstall OpenOffice, download a new copy from http://www.openoffice.org/download then verify the download.
After the download has been verified (instructions are on the download page linked above), reinstall OpenOffice.


Should the OP not also delete the AOO profile before the reinstallation?

OT but a quote I saw.
I would gladly recommend Windows 10 to my worst enemy.

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Thu Feb 21, 2019 1:06 pm
by John_Ha
jrkrideau wrote:Should the OP not also delete the AOO profile before the reinstallation?

Definitely since the problem probably resides in the User Profile - see Resetting the user profile.

Something funny seems to be happening with Windows 10 as there have been several posts like this. See for example "Save As" and PDF export not working. The poster was very active but has gone quiet once it was stressed that deleting the User Profile was the solution.

Showing that a problem has been solved helps others searching so, if your problem is now solved, please view your first post in this thread and click the Edit button (top right in the post) and add [Solved] in front of the subject.

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Thu Feb 21, 2019 1:36 pm
by robleyd
John_Ha suggested in another topic with a very similar issue:
In Tools > Options > OpenOffice > General > tick Use OpenOffice dialogue boxes. This uses AOO function instead of Windows function to provide the pop-up Save window.

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Thu Feb 21, 2019 8:55 pm
by DFIH
Hello!

Thank you all for your help. I deleted the user profile and reinstalled Open Office 4.1.6 to Windows 10 but it still would not save the normal way. I was, however, able to save new files using this method:

robleyd wrote:John_Ha suggested in another topic with a very similar issue:
In Tools > Options > OpenOffice > General > tick Use OpenOffice dialogue boxes. This uses AOO function instead of Windows function to provide the pop-up Save window.


So I'm able to save new files again using the regular commands in the application, it's just slightly more cumbersome than the original way, since I have to manually redirect the location of the saved file rather than Windows remembering where previous files were saved. I don't know if I consider the problem solved, but this has helped me quite a bit.

Thank you!

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Thu Feb 21, 2019 10:32 pm
by RoryOF
This might be a Windows Defender problem. Perhaps a Win10 user would comment?

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Sat Feb 23, 2019 2:11 pm
by John_Ha
Reboot your PC in Safe Mode (Google for how).

Is it now OK? If so it is one of the programs which are started when Windows starts which is causing the problem. See Re: "Locked by Unknown User" after upgrade to 4.1.6

I am not sure if you can prevent Windows Defender starting???? IF you cannot check its settings to be sure it is allowing AOO full access to the PC.

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Tue Feb 26, 2019 2:37 am
by DFIH
John_Ha wrote:Reboot your PC in Safe Mode (Google for how).

Is it now OK? If so it is one of the programs which are started when Windows starts which is causing the problem. See Re: "Locked by Unknown User" after upgrade to 4.1.6

I am not sure if you can prevent Windows Defender starting???? IF you cannot check its settings to be sure it is allowing AOO full access to the PC.


safe mode doesn't fix. does this negate your other advice?

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Tue Feb 26, 2019 3:00 am
by RusselB
I wouldn't negate the suggested link or the suggestion to check the Windows Defender settings.
I'm also curious if you tried my first suggestion of repairing the installation and/or doing a fresh installation.

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Fri Mar 01, 2019 7:50 pm
by jtcroquet
I was having this problem with the latest update of windows 10. Couldn't save spreadsheets. Uninstalled Open Office and tried to re-install. It downloaded, but would not install. I finally found that if I went to windows defender and turned off the protected folder function, then I was able to install open office. Also the file save function in spreadsheet now works. The protected folder function can be found in windows defender under the virus protection icon.

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Sat Mar 02, 2019 12:58 am
by Bill
Is the "folder protection function" actually "Controlled Folder Access"? You should be able to change the Windows Defender settings to allow OpenOffice through Controlled Folder Access without turning off Controlled Folder Access.

[Solved] Windows Defender prevents file opening

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Sat Mar 23, 2019 7:49 pm
by DFIH
Hello thank you all for your continued interest.

I had repaired/ uninstalled/ reinstalled the application before with no improvement. There is nothing by the name of 'bitdefender' that I can find on the PC. And under Windows Security the Controlled Folder Access function was already switched off. So finally I tried the suggestion of uninstalling/ reinstalling in a folder in Downloads rather than on the desktop. This has not helped either. Since other people have had a similar problem I sense it may not be my cheap laptop, but it may in fact be that (Acer). While I understand this is something that *should* be fixable, I remain content with the minor fix of 'use open office dialogues' under tools > options > general.

Thank you, and I will try other suggestions if they come up.

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Tue Mar 26, 2019 1:31 pm
by John_Ha

Re: Cannot Save New Files

PostPosted: Thu May 09, 2019 9:37 pm
by Patoruzu45
DFIH wrote:Hello!

Thank you all for your help. I deleted the user profile and reinstalled Open Office 4.1.6 to Windows 10 but it still would not save the normal way. I was, however, able to save new files using this method:

robleyd wrote:John_Ha suggested in another topic with a very similar issue:
In Tools > Options > OpenOffice > General > tick Use OpenOffice dialogue boxes. This uses AOO function instead of Windows function to provide the pop-up Save window.


So I'm able to save new files again using the regular commands in the application, it's just slightly more cumbersome than the original way, since I have to manually redirect the location of the saved file rather than Windows remembering where previous files were saved. I don't know if I consider the problem solved, but this has helped me quite a bit.

Thank you!


I had the same problem, I have Windows 10 :crazy: and I couldn't do anything by checking Windows Defender, but with the AOO function works just fine.

Thanks.

Andrés